I ended up putting three quotes in. One to Butler Patches, one to Custompatches.net and some other chuckefuck site.
Butler and Custom sent me quotes right away. Butler called me but the sales rep they assigned to my order couldn't speak English very well. The quote was $170 for 50 patches.
The quote from Custom was $180 for 100 patches, veclro backed and full embroidery. Butler offers to match the price, but Custom patches is based in New York (where I live) and the woman I got on the phone was able to understand me and I was able to understand her.
I already placed the order.
The finalized design is as follows:

When I get the samples I will post back here with them and see what you think. I went with full embroidery which costs extra, twill may look better but I wasn't sure so depending on how the sample turns out we'll make the FINAL decision. The patch will be 3 by 3 inches. The same size as a Gearwhore patch and it will obviously be Circular.

The initial investment is done entirely by me. I'll be selling these patches once I get them. Since I ordered 100 there won't be a "everyone gets one" rule you can order as many as you like.
It'll probably be $5 a patch or something like that. I don't plan to sell all of them, but if I only ordered 50 than everyone would only get one and I'd sell whatever I had extra at the end of the day meaning some people wouldn't get two if they wanted two etc.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE FACEPUNCH PATCHES ARE HERE!


Pricing:
Domestic (USA):
Each patch is $5 and shipping is covered in the cost of the patch.
International:
Each patch is $5 (USD) and you must provide $1 (USD) for shipping. For example, if you buy three patches the total cost is $16.
Payment:
(I'm Sold Out)
Paypal is the preferred method of payment. When you place an order you will need to put the following information in the "Comments/Note" field.
Note posted:
Senders Name
Street Address
City, State, Zip Code
(Country if applicable)
Username
# of patches
I'd prefer you do it in that format so it'll be easier and faster for me to print labels. Add your username below that for reference and the number of patches you wish to purchase.
If you do not have a paypal you can mail me the money. I DO NOT ACCEPT CHECKS because if it bounces you're a dead motherfucker.
Provide the same information as listed above in the envelope.
INTERNATIONAL:
Paypal is the ONLY method to purchase patches International as I wouldn't know what to do with your commie money. Provide the same details as listed above, as far as I know that's all I'll need but I may have to communicate with you later because I've never shipped/mailed things International
PS: Canada counts as International.
If you have any questions you can use the email I listed or post them here and I'll do my best to work with you.
The first batch will probably be mailed out on Monday. Tuesday latest if some disaster does not permit me to send them Monday.